Search This Blog

Saturday, November 23, 2013

Why Leaning Towards the Poles Leads to Losing at the Polls


As a teenager and budding, enthusiastic activist, there was no question of my affiliations and political leanings. The mother of a friend of mine worked at a women’s health center that performed abortions. My friend and I would often volunteer at the center and have to cross protest lines to get in the front door. On any given day ending in “y,” you would find my friend and me going toe-to-toe outside the center’s doors with nuns who were holding plastic baby dolls covered in ketchup. After one scathing exchange that left me shaking and in tears, my friend’s mother asked me, “Do you think anything you are saying to them is changing their minds?”

I was stunned, because her tone felt non-supportive. What did she mean? I was fighting the good fight, and what I was saying was making sense. It should change their minds. I’m not the one standing out there holding a toy doused in kitchen condiments.

Her lesson took a few more years to resonate. Of course the nuns didn’t change their minds. I may not have been holding a ketchup-covered Betsy Wetsy, but to those nuns, I must have looked unhinged and insane. After all, I was defending the center so vigorously that I was screaming through tears. Even if I had some great points buried in my rage, they probably couldn’t even understand what I was saying. In retrospect, all I likely accomplished that day was to reinforce their opinions about what kind of people support "those kinds of places."

As I grew and remained an engaged activist, I learned that all my friend’s mother was really trying to tell me was that the extreme side of any argument rarely wins the point. This became readily apparently as I became more involved in political activism. We are ripe with examples of how extreme right and left rhetoric and decisions have brought down top leaders and destroyed legacies. When you reflect on Clinton’s presidency, most people immediately recall the scandals and affairs that nearly got him impeached. When I remember Reagan’s presidency, I remember his extreme anti-humanitarian stance during the AIDS crisis. Nixon and Watergate, Bush and weapons of mass destruction – every time we swing the nation too far in any one direction, the results tend to be pretty damning.

As always, I like to throw in a few numbers to put things into perspective. Greenpeace is arguably the world’s largest and most recognized environmental protection organization. At its peak, Greenpeace boasted 4.8 million members worldwide. They were known as mavericks chaining themselves to trees, attacking whaling ships and oil tankers, and almost always getting themselves on the news. It was guerrilla activism for maximum exposure, and the organization enjoyed a boom in membership playing to those extremes. Fast forward 15 years, and membership is down to 2.8 million worldwide, and you don’t see so many news reports about a Greenpeace activist trying to board an oil tanker. Instead, you see articles about Greenpeace organizations setting up meetings and conference with local and national government representatives. They have gone from throwing themselves in front of whaling ships to presenting Powerpoint slides in front of legislators, to far greater effect.

The Greenpeace of today learned the lesson that my friend’s mother imparted a long time ago: You can’t change your audience’s mind if you don’t understand who your audience is.  You hear about the North Pole and the South Pole, but people live somewhere in between.

It’s a timely lesson for today’s political climate in which every possible media outlet is saturated in extreme reactions to the Affordable Care Act, same-sex marriage, and abortion. There are filibusters and protests filled with hate speech, and even movements to impeach the president over disagreements with the policies of his administration. We all watch and read these stories, and we may even agree with one side or the other – we are all amazingly astute couch politicians – but the polls prove it time and time again: when push comes to shove, the majority of us vote pretty close to the middle. We may staunchly stand our Republican and Democratic grounds, but we never vote for the tree-hugging whale ship chasers.

I think this is a particularly poignant lesson for the vocal right-wing faction that is dominating the news and social media posts today. Exposure doesn’t equal votes or power, and the numbers don’t lie. The reality is that Tea Party membership has been steadily declining for the past three years. Tea Party affiliated candidates have lost 20% of seats in Congress, and the movement has lost 40% of its active regional charters across the country. There’s a reason liberals, moderates and Democrats joke about wanting to see a Ted Cruz-Sarah Palin ticket in 2016. We know that will all but guarantee a failed presidential bid for the Republicans while providing a cornucopia of material for comic fodder.

Like Greenpeace, I have greatly tempered my activism. I still lean heavily to the left on most issues, but I appreciate that the real work gets done in the middle ground where people spend their daily lives. My olive branch of sorts to the Republican Party is this: get as far away from the Tea Party and the ultra-conservatives as you can. You will never win an election campaigning against equal rights and women’s issues, nor will you win an election by trying to deny people access to healthcare. You will not win elections by ranting against an issue if you don’t start talking about a reasonable solution. You may get the most likes on Facebook or the most views on YouTube, but you simply will not get enough votes when you play to the poles.

No comments:

Post a Comment