I’ve written in before, and I’ll write it again now. As far
back as I can remember, a date that I’ll admit is becoming a moving target as I
lurch toward AARP eligibility, I wanted to be a star. I would tear through
entertainment news like the gayest kid in the neighbor (shockingly, that title
was actually taken by someone else, just for the record). Hours were spent devouring
the gossip magazines my mother subscribed to and the ones I would shamelessly
read in every waiting room. I was always so disappointed when I would get to a
new doctor’s office or some other professional space and find that the
magazines were all about sports or cars. For spite, I would pick up any huge
women’s fashion magazine – seriously, why are some of those magazines the size
of a Prius? – in a form of protest, and sometimes be wonderfully surprised to
find a famous star either on the cover or in one of the articles inside.
Magazines, movies, awards shows – these were my motivators.
I wanted that kind of fame and fortune and attention, and I could think of
nothing more wonderful than being admired. I was prepared for critics and for
the demands of being a public figure with a public life, because as corny as it
sounded now and even then, I knew I would be happy if I inspired just one other
big-dreaming gay kid to chase his or her moment in the sun.
Even now as I inch toward the half-century mark, that dream
hasn’t changed. I still write screenplays and plays and every once in a while
think about who I would thank while holding tight to a shiny, gold award. But
who am I kidding? We all know I would take the speech as an opportunity to be
unbelievably grateful. How many people ever get to experience that kind of
reward and recognition? If I didn’t get up there and project 30 seconds of pure
gratitude and amazement, I would never be able to look in the eyes of that one
young dreamer without whom I wouldn’t be standing in the spotlight.
Yesterday, I caught a headline that read “Shia LaBeouf
Retiring From All Public Life,” apparently worn down by attacks on his artistic
integrity (mind you, this is the same man who, a day earlier, shared an article
about how he texted a photo of his penis to a director in order to get a film
role). Mr. LaBeouf, a young actor of significant fame and fortune who came up
through the Disney ranks, is another in a long line of celebrities who seem to
regularly lose their minds, threaten to give up the dream, and somehow always
manage to do it on social media. He is yet another person who vows to walk away
from the rigors of public life, all martyred and misunderstood, but still
keeping the cars, the houses, the money and all of the spoils that were built
on the backs of the significantly less wealthy fans without whom he would have
no forum in which to throw his temper tantrum.
It is the living definition of juvenile ingratitude on a
digitally epic scale. And it is absolutely inexcusable.
These stories enrage and disappoint those of us who aspire
to be successful artists, and who would sacrifice any number of things to
achieve the level of success that these celebrities attain. Any artist with any
serious aspiration to this fame, particularly in a day and age when every
breath we take is documented on the Internet, fully understands that public
life means just that: you are public property. You can’t in your right mind
star in a film that grosses more than $1B worldwide, go on a months-long press
tour to promote the film, manipulate every piece of media you can get your
hands on to drive up the box office revenues, and then expect to walk away at
5pm like it’s the end of a work day. How many of us worker bees walk away from
our jobs at the end of any given work day and truly walk way? Do you check email on weekends or after
hours? Do you answer that one phone call during dinner – just that one call,
honey, I promise – because you know that the workload you face tomorrow will be
exponentially worse if you don’t take the call?
We do this as people who do not willingly identify as public
figures nor enjoy all of the perks that can come with a high pop culture
profile. We do our jobs and are subjected to performance reviews of our
“artistic integrity” every day – our raises and bonuses and promotions depend
on putting ourselves and our work up for judgment that is even more crucial
than what a film actor faces from a critic. If you think that’s unfair, cull
through your memory banks for every time a mistake or a less than stellar work
performance, accurate or not, negatively impacted your ability to earn more
money, get a bigger share of the bonus pool or vault you to the next step in
your career.
And then think of every terrible film that has a low
approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, an aggregate score of multiple film
reviews, that went on to make some ungrateful actor – how much did you make on
those “Transformers” films, Mr. LaBeouf? – a stinking fortune. Then think of
how many additional films and opportunities came Mr. LaBeouf’s way as the
result of that badly reviewed work. How often does that happen in your career?
So yes, it is offensive when said actor/celebrity/public
figure pouts over being criticized in a public forum. You knew what you signed
up for when you chased the fame brass ring. It feels like a complete cheat and
a deep insult to the fans who made your career to complain about how difficult
it is to handle the attention that comes with public life. It’s not like there
aren’t dozens of stories every hour on every social media outlet detailing
every single minute of being famous. Watching famous people film themselves has
become it’s own high-grossing form of entertainment. It’s a big fat Kardashian
world we live in, so how on earth can anyone with a pulse not understand the
facets that come with putting yourself in the public eye. I’m sorry, Mr. LaBeouf,
but if the leader of the free world can get taken to task on the Internet over
his choice of household pet, your artistic integrity (is your dick that small? ) is fair game.
Granted, I’m sure the fame game was different back in the
so-called Golden Age of Hollywood. Back then, studios ruled the roost, and
stars were made and broken on their loyalties to studios and the moguls who ran
them like miniature, nearly magical kingdoms. They could create publicity
machines and images out of thin air because they had two things that the public
figures of today no longer enjoy: a sense of mystery, and the benefit of
journalistic integrity. The Louis B. Mayers and David O. Selznicks of a bygone
era didn’t have to look over their shoulders for some stranger on a smart
phone.
The fame game changed, in a big way. Fifty years ago, movie
fans would wait with baited breath for carefully groomed stories and images to
hit magazine stands and news reels to catch up on all of the latest about their
favorite stars. Just look at how many gay actors could successfully stay in the
closet thanks to studios that could carefully control and manipulate the
messages that the public got to see. Back then, a sex scandal sent your career
into a tailspin and your reputation never recovered.
The media IS the public now. Some guy with an iPhone can
capture a photo or video of anyone, just about anywhere, and with the power of
apps and wi-fi, broadcast that image to a global audience in a few dexterous
pushes of buttons. He shares with two friends, and so on, and so on, and a
viral sensation builds, explodes and blows over sometimes all within the same
day. Anyone can become an instant paparazzo just by being in the right place at
the right time and having a good command of quick reflexes to catch it all on
camera. We now pay to watch the real lives of people who used their sex
scandals to get famous. If that doesn’t tell you that the game has changed,
then I can’t imagine that anything will drive the point home more clearly.
Something funny did happen on the way to fame and fortune
for the stars like Mr. LaBeouf who seem so put out by it all. They seem to
forget that you can only understand adoration when you’ve experienced the polar
opposite. No one has ever created art that is universally beloved. Even the
Bible, the “greatest book ever written,” is not immune to constant scrutiny. If
the media can take God’s word to task, it seems reasonable to assume that Transformers might get a detractor or two. The days of public figures having
power over the media no longer exist. That world is gone. Like it or not,
everything you do, everything we do,
is up for public consumption. Don’t kid yourself into thinking that setting
privacy filters on your public profile makes one bit of difference. Facebook
isn’t exactly the high bar we’ve set for online security.
To some degree, most of us put ourselves out there as public
figures every time we blog, post, Instagram, text, and share. For those like
Mr. LaBeouf who do so on a grand scale with grand rewards, it’s a complete
cheat and pretty cowardly to duck and run on Twitter when you so blatantly used
every media outlet and fan to get to be as rich and famous as you are. The
public demands a lot because they deserve to demand it. Stop and think of what
it means, financially, for a family on a modest income to afford cable
television, or take their kids to the movies, buy the toys and the merchandise,
etc. They are the ones you hurt by sulking over some critic’s barbs and wires.
Those critics are always going to be there, praising one
piece of work one day, and trashing another piece of your work the next. That
family that goes to the movies and buys the toys won’t be so loyal. So go
ahead, threaten to retire and walk away from it all. See if the public welcomes
you back in six months, or see if you been replaced by someone who understands
why they are famous in the first place.