Search This Blog

Sunday, January 5, 2014

A Pronoun Problem: Freedom OF Religion versus Freedom FROM Religion


I do not claim to be a Constitutional scholar. I studied U.S. history the way most of us did: a few classes in grade school, some electives in college, and that was about it. My grades were always excellent, though I freely admit that I have gotten fuzzy on the names and details. It is only now as an adult, with Constitutional issues that impact my day-to-day existence, that I realize I should have paid greater attention beyond learning just enough to get an A.

As a student of the public school system in a fairly liberal district, I grew up with a healthy respect for the separation of Church and State. I remember one shining example of just how seriously the community adhered to that separation. One morning during the four-year character building exercise that was high school, we students were called to the auditorium for a presentation from a guest lecturer.  The presentation started out harmlessly enough with a former professional athlete I had never heard of recounting his example of dropping out of school, falling into a pattern of substance abuse, and stressing how important it was for all of us young adults to make the right decisions. It was pretty standard after-school special kind of stuff.

Then he abruptly changed course and began to credit his salvation to his deep faith, his dedication to prayer, and to letting Jesus into his life. I was sitting next to my friend – the one whose mother worked at women’s clinic – looking at her in total disbelief. After all, we were one of the first schools to stop the morning prayer and the Pledge of Allegiance, so hearing this person openly discuss his religious beliefs was a jolt. It was even more jolting was when he handed out cards and asked us to fill in our names and indicate whether or not we accepted Jesus as our Lord and Savior.

By the following morning, the school was responding to a number of outraged parents who claimed that the schools’ right to freedom of religion imposed on their right to freedom from religion. The furor died quickly as the school scrambled to appease the angry mob. I never knew how or even if the situation was resolved to everyone’s satisfaction, but I do know that there was never another assembly that even remotely included any religious references.

This memory sprang to mind as I was reading a story about same-sex couple that was denied wedding cake service by a bakery owner who cited his religious beliefs. Citing those religious beliefs, the baker stood by his claim that he should have the right to refuse service as he sees fit. The couple, on the other hand, claimed discrimination, and filed a formal complaint with the State about being denied service.

My first thought was that the baker was an idiot for denying business. As more and more states legally recognize same-sex marriage, it seems to me that any merchant with a toe in the wedding industry should be rolling out the red carpet and listening to the sweet “cha-ching” of the cash registers. I almost admired the baker’s conviction and commitment to his beliefs over financial gain, but then I kept reading and re-reading the article, and I kept focusing on the baker’s statement that he just didn’t think God would approve of him making a wedding cake for a same-sex couple.

The more I contemplated the baker’s claim to know what God would approve, the more I kept thinking of questions to ask the baker. How many wedding cakes has he made for opposite-sex couples that have cheated on each other, had sex outside of marriage, and/or have gotten divorced? Has he ever made cakes for people who lied, coveted, failed to respect their parents, not kept the Sabbath holy, or taken the Lord’s name in vain? Is God okay with making wedding cakes for people who commit those sins? Is it just cakes for homosexuals that ruffle God’s feathers? Does the baker have a formula to determine the cake approval rating for sinners?

People who commented on the article argued that the same-sex couple should just go to another baker, because it is unfair for the baker to have to go against his religious beliefs to run his own business. Others argued that many couples live in rural areas in which merchant options are limited, and those couples should not be forced to go outside the communities that benefit from their tax dollars and spending – the communities they support and call home - in order to get a wedding cake.

It may sound easy to simply say that the same-sex couple should go to another bakery, but that is simply deceiving. If merchants have to start advertising that they will or will not sell to same-sex couples, how is that any different than having a “no coloreds allowed” sign on your front door?  This starts to veer into slippery territory that feels a little too much like the “separate but equal” legislation of our not too distant past. We all know how well that worked the last time we tried it.

I realize the challenge of reconciling faith with change. I think it’s fair to say that most organized religions are slow to adapt to social progress. It is also fair to say that legislation can be just as far behind the eight ball. Civil movements and change take time. It has taken generation after generation to secure equality for women and for minorities, and we’re still not 100% there on any count. I may never see fully realized rights for gay men and women in my lifetime, and hope lies in couples like the one in the bakery article to keep pushing the movement for equality forward.

And yes, the scales will go off balance for a while. Some of the comments from the article were from people expressing that everything is about homosexuality now, and that the gay agenda is being forced down their throats. I would challenge those people to stop and take stock of how much of life is geared toward heterosexuality. I would also challenge them to try to understand what it feels like to have to fight from a minority perspective, since they have enjoyed centuries of majority privilege. If the scales have to tip a little to other side, that will still never make up for all of the years that gay men and women have lived in the shadow of inequality.

Freedom of religion cannot exist without freedom from religion. I wouldn’t expect to enter a bakery and be subjected to religious requirements in order to receive service any more than I would expect to sit down for a public school assembly and be forced to answer questions about my spiritual belief system. Religion becomes dangerous when any one of us starts to believe that we can speak on behalf of God. If you don’t believe me, pick any one of a hundred atrocities over the past centuries that have been carried about by men claiming to know God’s intentions.

I am not a religious man, but I think it’s safe to say that God is not a petty tyrant who would rain disapproval on a baker for making a wedding cake for a gay couple. If God is going to smite someone, I think a person who uses God’s name to support inequality is a far more likely target.

No comments:

Post a Comment