Search This Blog

Wednesday, December 30, 2020

I Can Think of Five Million Reasons to Keep Funding the Arts

The story goes something like this: when asked to cut funding for the arts to support Britain’s efforts during World War II, Winston Churchill answered with the short reply, “Then what are we fighting for?” As it turns out, there is no recorded evidence that Mr. Churchill ever spoke that iconic line. Some histories chalk it up to urban legend, something repeated and told so often that people simply accept it as fact. Even if he never spoke those words, I feel that Mr. Churchill wouldn’t mind them being credited to his legacy.

There is documentation, however, of Churchill saying something equally powerful about the importance of the arts. In 1938, he said “The arts are essential to any complete national life. The State owes it to itself to sustain and encourage them ... ill fares the race which fails to salute the arts with the reverence and delight which are their due.” With this on record, it doesn’t seem like misguided artistic license to think that Churchill may well have been behind the shorter, more famous quote. 


The arts have been at the center of the most celebrated societies in history, to the extent that entire periods of our history are defined in part by the artistic movements and philosophies of their days. The arts illuminate our lives, from our day-to-day existence to the political and social climates of the times we are in. They inspire us and provide a look into ourselves and our world, and often an escape from both. The best of the arts entertain and educate, giving us glimpses into bygone eras and helping us piece together ancient civilizations and cultures. We have learned so much of what we know of the past through art, from the grandest works to to stories and mythologies handed down from generation to generation. 


In short, the arts have an undeniable impact on us as a society and as individuals. Studies provide quantifiable data that tells us that exposure to the arts and arts programs throughout a student’s educational journey has a direct, positive impact on grades and engagement. The studies highlight that students in schools with robust arts programs are more likely to stay in the education system, graduate from high school, and continue their studies.


If you need further proof, consider these statistics. More than five million people in the United States are employed within the arts and cultural institutions. An additional 330,000 people that are not primarily employed in the arts hold secondary jobs in the field. The arts generate $166 billion dollars in revenue for the U.S., resulting in $27.5 billion dollars in local, state, and federal taxes. Add in the film, television, radio, and streaming/web arts and entertainment, and these numbers increase exponentially. There are single films alone that pull in more than $1 billion. As the saying goes, that’s a lot of cheddar.


Arts and culture are a component of a financially sound economy. They are not only worth fighting for, they provide a portion of the tax revenues that give us the means to fight with. It enrages and frustrates me that our current president, Donald Trump, is spending his waning days in the Oval Office, and in reality the bulk of his presidential tenure, categorizing the arts as pork: low hanging financial fruit that is easy to cut from budgets and stimulus packages because they are seen as frivolous spending. Never mind that taxes collected from arts and cultural institutions contribute to the national budget and those stimulus packages, or that many artists need the stimulus payments. For Trump and many before and likely after him, the arts are always one of the first (if not the first) offerings on the chopping block.


I appreciate that people experiencing unemployment, mounting healthcare costs, difficulty or inability paying rent and putting food on the table - all of these overwhelming obstacles - can look at funding for the arts as frivolous. Millions of dollars for museums? Grants for ballet? At a glance, it can seem like helping a laid off service worker, for example, should be a higher priority than keeping a local museum afloat. 


But that discounts the fact that museums, theaters, and other cultural institutions also had to furlough people and put artists out of work. Contrary to popular opinion, working actors on the Broadway stage are not rolling in dough. It is a very select few that vault to a level of celebrity that lands them $20 million per film with a cut of the profits and merchandising. The majority artists never reach those heights and spend the better part of their lives holding down other jobs to make ends meet. And that doesn’t take into account the people that work behind the scenes. Shutting down a Broadway production or a film eliminates work for all of the technicians and support staff that keep these institutions running. A collapsed economy leads to shrinking donations, which can be a significant portion of a non-profit arts organization’s budget. If people can’t pay the rent, it’s safe to assume they aren’t writing checks to save the community theater down the street. The economy collapsed for artists and workers in the arts every bit as much as it collapsed for Middle America.


I realize that the way in which we experience art is changing. The advent of the digital age has created all manner of new avenues of creative expression. We can see art online and stream symphonies and stage performances, and watch films on demand on a half dozen devices within our homes. Maybe the future of movie theaters and live theater is a bit uncertain, but even in digital formats, artists have to earn a living. It’s great when artists go online and help bring a little brightness in a world that desperately needs it, but we tend to forget that those artists are fighting for survival and facing the same uncertain future as we are. We don’t know what the new normal will look like, but the general consensus is that life as we know it will be permanently altered by this experience. We have no choice but to learn some tough lessons from this pandemic and come out on the other side smarter and stronger. Change is inevitable and frankly, necessary.


I for one cannot entertain the concept of a future, whatever state that may be, without the arts, without cultural institutions, and without entertainment. I worked in regional theater for a number of years. I worked for an organization that provided grants to local arts organizations. I sat on those grant panels and helped make tough decisions on funding. Funds were limited, and we had to do as much as we could for as many organizations as possible, and then help them with fundraising activities to make up the difference. If you think entertainment is expendable, really consider what the world would be like if we couldn’t escape into a film, fill the soundtrack of our lives with music, or lose ourselves in a book.


I have one granddaughter that is now five years old, and two grandchildren on the way. There is so much I want for them, the most important of which is a world in which they have the choice to be an artist, to paint, to dance, to sculpt, to act, to write - to create and inspire and also keep a roof over their heads and dinner on the table. I don’t want them sacrificing their dreams and their talents because we eliminated options for them without considering the long-term consequences.


This has been a tough year across the board. I certainly don’t advocate that any person struggling is more important than any other. The individual battles are our own but they are part of a collective experience that has touched everyone to some degree. Artists and the people that make their living in the arts are woven into that collective.  Categorizing arts funding as pork diminishes how out-of-work artists impact the bigger picture. The arts is not some abstract thing we need to save. The arts are people. If we turn our backs on those people, then what are we fighting for?


Sunday, December 6, 2020

Yes, 74 Million People Can Be Wrong

Not so long ago - 1975 to exact - a struggling and somewhat disenchanted advertising copywriter named Gary Dahl, created a marketing concept that was intended as a joke. He envisioned a pet that was all upsides: quiet, no-maintenance, and an absolute steal at a mere three dollars and 95 cents. For just a minor investment of four dollars and change, factoring in tax, you could walk into a store and buy a Pet Rock. 


For those too young to remember, this is a true story. Google that shit. Dahl took ordinary, smooth, oval-shaped rocks not unlike something you would see in a landscaping bed around any house in the neighborhood, packaged them in boxes, and sold 1.5 million Pet Rocks. You did not read that incorrectly, nor did you have a minor stroke that blurred your vision. More than a million people in just a few months time made the Pet Rock one of the most talked-about fads of the 70’s. And before you think that 1.5 million people is not that impressive, remember that he achieved those sales long before the advent of personal computers, smart phones, the Internet, and social media. 


Dahl convinced more than a million people via old-school print and word-of-mouth advertising that the rocks were the ultimate pets that didn’t have to be fed, didn’t have to be walked, and didn’t cost you hundreds of dollars in shampooed carpets and reupholstered furniture. As the old saying goes, coined in 1926, “No one ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American public.”


What if Dahl had developed this scheme to market rocks in the age of the Internet? How many Pet Rocks could Dahl have sold if they were trending on Twitter, blowing up Facebook, and captured on video in the hands of hundreds of Instagram influencers?


74 million, apparently. 


In 2020, thanks to his lifetime practice of capitalizing on the underestimation of American intelligence, our generation’s Pet Rock salesman, Donald Trump, sold 74 million people on marketing campaign to discredit the election process. His claims of voter fraud are unsubstantiated. His attorneys have presented no reliable evidence and even less reliable witness testimony. His legal team has filed 50 lawsuits to dispute the integrity of the election process and 49 of those lawsuits have been dismissed.


Yet 74 million people are protesting at state capitol buildings, sending messages of hate and threats to voting officials, and taking to every form of media to chant “Stop the Steal.” They are holding their version of a pet rock - incredulous claims with no proof - and tossing those rocks right into the heart of democracy. In Dahl’s case, the worst that happened was people got duped out of four bucks and comically shamed into a lifetime of never admitting it.


At least you could have used the Pet Rock as a paperweight or skipped it across a pond (I leave it to you to make the obvious “sink like a stone” comparison). It was a moment in time that lasted a few months and has become an amusing footnote in pop culture. There is much more at stake in the snake oil that Trump is selling. He will leave the Oval Office in a month and the intensity of the narrative around election fraud may subside, but the damage will reverberate through generations. This will not be a footnote in history. This will change history and change the way that nearly half of a nation’s citizens feel about the election process, the power of the presidency, and the validity of mainstream media. President Trump has done more than dupe people out of money. He has convinced them that his pet rock is real, and he didn’t need a single fact to make his case.


Those of us that did not vote for Trump in 2016 and turned out in even larger numbers to not vote for him again in 2020 have been left scratching our heads yet again, standing in disbelief, wondering how our fellow man - neighbors, friends, and in many cases, family - fell for it not once but twice. We begrudgingly gave people some benefit of the doubt in 2016, struggling to support the sentiment that people voted for Donald Trump because he was new and different and unproven, and it was time to make a change from the lifelong politicians that typically take the White House. But after witnessing four years of disastrous policies, 23,000 (and counting) verified lies, more than 400 days spent golfing, and the tragic and devastating results from  the lack of response to a global pandemic, we just don’t get it. 


It’s not just the laundry list of poor performances listed above. It’s the unfulfilled promises that were allegedly the reason so many people voted for Trump in the first place. It’s the infrastructure week that never happened. It’s the best-ever healthcare plan that was going to replace the Affordable Care Act - in the first 30 days of his presidency, no less. It was the border wall that was going to be built and paid for by Mexico, of which only 25 miles of new construction has been completed (at a cost far exceeding three dollars and 95 cents). The manufacturing jobs did not come rushing back to the United States. The coal industry didn’t make a miraculous comeback.


And even if you could look past all of those failures to deliver, it seemed inconceivable to 80 million of us that 74 million of our friends, neighbors, and family could vote for a man whose inability to face a health crisis has cost nearly 300,000 American lives, not to mention crippled the national economy and pushed the healthcare system and its workers to the point of collapse. Simply put, how could so many people make one of the most important decision of their lives with nothing holding up the marketing scheme. 74 million people failed to notice that not only did their candidate fail on nearly every plan from his first campaign, he failed to even HAVE a plan for his second campaign. 74 million people looked at a man with a terrible track record and that had not a single idea to move the nation forward and bought a second Pet Rock.

 

It has been 45 years since Gary Dahl turned his little marketing joke into an inexplicable national success. He underestimated the intelligence of the American public and proved that you can fool some people all of the time. Donald Trump may be the worst President in modern history, but he said it best himself. “I like stupid people. They vote for me.” 


Mr. Dahl died one year before Trump launched his first presidential campaign. I can’t help but think that he missed the marketing opportunity of a lifetime.

Sunday, November 29, 2020

America Is Not Broken, But We’re Working on It

I recently had the privilege of attending the annual Out & Equal Workplace Summit, the world’s largest event focused on workplace advocacy for the LGBTQIA+ community. It was a virtual gathering of more than 5,000 people of all titles and career levels from more than 50 countries, and the first time I had ever been to a conference or event of that magnitude that was geared toward me, people like me, and people across the spectrum of the queer community. This was early October in the critical days leading up to the most intense presidential election I have experienced in my nearly 40 years of voting. There was much to discuss.


Shortly after the election, right about the time that it was looking clearer and clearer that Joe Biden and Kamala Harris would be our next President and Vice President-elect, Out & Equal sponsored another virtual event, a town hall of sorts, featuring LGBTQIA+ leaders and national news anchors discussing the impact of an election that took place while a pandemic continued to spiral out of control. At one point, one of the panelists remarked that while she was happy and somewhat encouraged by the Biden-Harris victory, she felt even more tense than the days leading up to the election. With the shift in the make-up of the Supreme Court and a lame duck president that we all knew had a penchant for acting out of spite, she said this was no time to relax. 


“I don’t know why I expected this, because I know better, but somehow after the election victory, I wanted to wake up without this constant, underlying sense of anxiety that has been my existence for the past four years,” she said, clearly striking a chord with her fellow panelists. I was listening to the panel with two friends and coworkers who had attended the Workplace Summit with me, and we immediately messaged each other with nearly identical thoughts: this panelist perfectly vocalized what each of us was feeling but couldn’t quite articulate. Victory in the White House came at the price of a SCOTUS majority that could undo decades of progress for the LGBTQIA+ community, with no way for us to exercise a vote to change the outcome.


If you have read my blog or followed me on social media, you know that I wear my politics and my passion on my sleeve. I was front and center as someone that had tremendous difficulty reconciling the results of the 2016 presidential election. I watched then candidate Trump speak and followed his actions and never dreamed that the nation I grew up learning about and believing in would self-inflict such a deep wound. But it did, and nearly did again just a few weeks ago.


I realized after some time that I wasn’t just anxious for the LGBTQIA+ community and the potential ramifications of a conservative Court. I was disappointed that the United States I grew up on, the one in which I was told the stories of how we as a people come together in a crisis, was not the United States I was seeing and hearing all around me. We are in crisis mode, in the midst of a pandemic logging new and higher infection and death rates, and people are debating and questioning the constitutionality of face mask mandates and preventative measures. Stunningly large numbers of people legitimately believe that the pandemic was a ploy and a hoax perpetrated by one political party to undermine the current presidential administration, which in essence means that this group of people also believes that 80 million voters are willing to sacrifice 300,000 friends, family, and neighbors in order to win. 


I also realized that I was disappointed that I expected anything but this divided reaction. I came of age in the late 1970’s and early 1980’s, embracing my queerness just as this mysterious and deadly gay cancer was cropping up in various parts of the country. I watched as the disease was given a name, as the community around me literally started to disappear before my eyes, and I watched as a conservative government and a large number of my fellow citizens failed to come together to help those in need. Instead of advocating for healthcare funding and research to help stem the pandemic, a nation stood divided. LGBTQIA+ people got fired from jobs, lost everything they had worked for, and died with little to no dignity or compassion. Like a stubborn refusal to wear a mask, an overwhelming segment of the population did not step up to the plate when crisis struck.


We came together after the tragic events of 9/11. We know it can happen. We know we can set aside differences to focus on something that is bigger than the individual. We can sacrifice for the greater good. That is our history: rations during the war, women going to work in the factories - we are the nation that sold war bonds and collected cans and held up Rosie the Riveter as a symbol of just how far we were willing to go to protect the idea and ideals of the United States. We stepped into airports and took off our shoes, emptied our carry on bags, had our bodies scanned, and agreed to random pat downs and screenings. If we can do all of these things, it seems almost ridiculous to protest wearing a mask in public. Is that really the sword so many people are willing to fall on?


I wish I knew how to get us back to the kind of resolve we had during the world wars and in the wake of the tragedies of 9/11. Perhaps we as a nation are wired to respond differently when we perceive that the threat is coming from outside our own borders. Perhaps it’s easier to say “China virus” and not look at our own day-to-day behavior and how we are contributing to the crisis. Is that the pattern? Are we too scared to face ourselves and to accept responsibility when the chips are down?


I miss the America that was passed down to me by my grandparents and great-grandparents, the America of my school textbooks and assemblies, the one I stood up for every day in home room to pledge my allegiance to. I believe with all of my being that this house divided will fall if we don’t find some path back to being the “united” states. As tough as it is and as difficult as it feels, that path starts at home. Find a way to accept the people across the aisle and see them as people and not as a political party. Elect people that remember that they are public servants sworn to represent all of their constituents and not just the ones that voted for them. Protest when something feels fundamentally wrong. Step up when others are hurting.


And remember that the actions we take and the words we speak now are the legacies that we leave for our children and grandchildren. All of it is documented on the Internet for others to search and find long after we are gone. I do not want to be remembered as the generation that let a pandemic spiral out of control because it was more important to focus on our differences than to reach across the aisle. We don’t have to agree with each other nor do we have to like each other, but speaking for myself, I would rather have something to fight for than someone to fight with.