Search This Blog

Sunday, October 13, 2013

The Lesser of Two Evils: Why Rom-Coms Are More Dangerous Than Porn


First, if you haven’t seen the film Don Jon, do yourself a favor and head to the theater before it quietly disappears from view. The film is far more insightful than the trailers, which lead you to believe there is little substance beyond the story of a clichéd “Guido” who works out, bangs chicks and drives a car that proudly announces his overabundance of testosterone. At it’s heart, the film is really challenging our tendencies to blur the lines between fantasy and reality, specifically when it comes to how we engage in relationships. It’s not exactly a groundbreaking premise, but it is presented in smart and insightful porn vs. rom-com construct that compelled me to put this to paper.

Let’s do something most of us have probably never done: list all of the similarities between porn and any movie starring Meg Ryan, with the assumption that both have equal production values. Stick with me here:
·      Both feature attractive people who are completely unconvincing as romantic losers or people whose “girlfriends wont’ put out and are so horny.”
·      Both set up meet-cute scenes that just don’t happen in real life, no matter how much you hope the cable guy is going to look like Channing Tatum.
·      Both depict scenes of sex, or “love making,” that are so beautiful photographed that there’s no way your iPhone can compete.
·      Both give us characters that never have to experience a hardship that really bad music doesn’t help them overcome.
·      Both feature terrible dialogue and bad acting, and
Most importantly, both are perfectly designed to lure us into thinking we are seeing something we want and something we can emulate or recreate in our day-to-day lives.

Then we wonder why we get depressed, and we question why we as a culture have grown more and more dependent on drugs to even our moods, or pull us out of depressions, or keep our erections going through an entire weekend vacation. Yes, we work too hard and try to achieve too much, but how much of that is based on our belief that we can live up to the standards that we try to copy from films that are really meant to be nothing more than a 90-minute piece of escapism? When did we lose track of the fact that we go to movie theaters to be entertained, not to have Julia Roberts teach us how to fall in love? Why would we want her to teach us anyway? Look at the short life spans of so many Hollywood marriages, and that should be enough to tell you that whatever is happening up on screen is not translating to these celebrities’ real lives.

Granted, very few scenarios that tantalize us in porn play out in real-life (though there is a cable guy story I will share over drinks). You can argue that porn is degrading or twisted and often crosses the line into violence, though I’d argue back that being slapped during hot sex is a lot less damaging than having your heart broken over a fantasy Valentine’s Day gone horribly wrong. I think rom-coms are way more dangerous than porn for two very key reasons:
1.     Porn is honest about its intentions, and
2.     Porn has taught me way more than any rom-com ever has.

Porn may set the bar high on sex, but at least I can watch porn, learn some techniques, and try some things that are far more attainable than what is depicted in a rom-com. If I go buy a new toy and try it with disastrous results, the worst I walk away with is a good story and a few towels I have to wash on the heavy cycle. When shit hits the fan because I try to recreate some rom-com set up, it ends in a broken heart, some therapy and half eaten cans of cake frosting. Porn never makes me sad, hate anyone or gain weight. Porn has never compelled me to stalk an ex on Facebook, slash anyone’s tires or drive past their house 200 times while eating Nutella out of the jar with my fingers.

Don’t judge.

I joke with a dear friend of mine, who loves rom-coms and movies-of-the-week, that she is addicted to all of those networks that I lump together as The Unrealistic Relationship Channel. I watch her and so many other bright and beautiful souls struggling to live up to an ideal that, like being a size zero, just isn’t healthy.
It’s not about sparks and fireworks and soul mates, because I believe that connections happen between all of us on some level, and it’s so limiting to force yourself to make that connection once and ignore all the others. Sure it’s romantic to meet someone at the top of the Empire State Building, but how do you live up to that? What do you do to top that experience? How on earth can anyone be expected live up to that concept of love?

True, I don’t look like guys in porn films. I am not hung to the point that I lose balance when I get an erection, nor do I have a perfect body. The FedEx guy doesn’t “have a package for me” when he drops off my new purchase. Porn is silly, but to me, porn is in on the joke. I’m pretty sure porn directors don’t create their films under the stress of worrying about Oscar season. They want to get us horny, get us off and get paid. Not exactly the loftiest ambition, but it’s a mighty profitable one.

The real danger to me is the rom-com set up for failure. Unlike bad sex, which usually turns into a great story you can share when you’re hammered, bad relationships truly devastate people. I can joke a friend out of a sex toy mishap, but I’ve lost friends to the depression that sets in when life doesn’t live up to the movies. I’m not saying we should give up on love. And I’m definitely not saying we should all become addicted to porn and build a naked room when the kids move out.

Surely, though, we can take a step back and remember that it’s just the movies, and allow ourselves to be entertained, even if just for a few minutes.

No comments:

Post a Comment