Search This Blog

Sunday, November 10, 2013

What Happened to the “H” in HR?


Up until last week, I had never heard the term “job crush.”  When I first saw this term in the title of an article, I formulated the definition from my current employment circumstances and assumed the term referred to that crushing feeling of being trapped in a professional position that is going nowhere, held back by poor management and a company whose weak senior leadership places a crushing burden on the next level of supervisors (of which I am one). Excited to get tips on how to deal with this, I started to read the article.  In retrospect, I guess you could say I was projecting just a little . . .

Per the author, a career consultant, “job crush” refers to the phenomenon that many job seekers experience in which they develop a “crush” on a company/position for which they have applied, and they suspend their overall job search to focus on this particular company or opportunity. I was surprised and delighted, as I have certainly fallen victim to this very experience. “Great,” I thought to myself. “I could use a little bolstering right now.” I’ve had a run of interesting and disappointing job search experiences, so the article was perfectly timed.

The career consultant who wrote the article opened with the following:

“Always assume you didn’t get the job,” she wrote. “All jobs are temporary, and it’s best to keep that in mind as you seek employment.”

While I can certainly understand the need to keep expectations in check during the interview process, and to always keep the search going while you are seeking a new job, her words were surprisingly defeatist. They also flew in the face of everything I was ever taught and still want to believe.

What is the point of doing research on a company and position, filling out all of the paperwork, taking time to go on the interview – often taking time away from a current job to do so – dressing in your best business attire, and walking in there completely prepared if you are supposed to assume you didn’t get the job and not care anyway because it’s only temporary? Call me crazy, but I don’t do the whole interview dog and pony show for positions and companies that don’t interest me in the long-term. That’s why we do research as job seekers and learn more about the role and company. That’s why we ask questions in the interviews and put our best foot forward – so these employers and companies see our potential and want to hire us and keep us on board.

Every job ad I reply to contains some version of the following statement: we are looking for a dedicated XXX who can grow with us. How does that translate into “every job is temporary?” If you want me to grow with you, that indicates that you want me to stick around. If that is the case, then shouldn’t I walk into this interview with the confidence of getting the job, rather than walk out assuming I didn’t get it? Why would XYZ Company want to hire someone for a growth position when that someone walks in the door already defeated and apparently already looking for the next job opportunity?

I think we can agree that if we’re lucky enough to get to the in-person interview stages, we need to give it 250%, because getting there is no small feat in today’s job market. You have to navigate unfriendly job websites, confusing job postings, tedious online applications and ridiculous turnaround times. You try to use all of the tools at your disposal to get noticed – emails, referrals from colleagues, LinkedIn, Facebook – anything that gets you past the HR software that is only looking for key words in your online resume. We should all add ‘search engine optimization professional” to our resumes, because that is what we’ve had to become just to get a phone screen.

Job crush can be debilitating, but HR needs to take some of the heat and a good share of the blame. In the past year, I have been through every kind of interview and scenario I could imagine: panel interviews, video interviews, conference calls, phone screens, meeting offsite for coffee, even having one employer call to tell me that my resume is amazing and she wishes she could afford me (and then wishing me luck and saying goodbye). During that time, I have been the top candidate for two companies that then opted “not to staff the position at this time.” I have been told more than once that I was definitely coming back from the final round of interviews only to be told upon me following up that an incumbent filled the position. I have gotten to the very end of the process; with my salary requirements clear as a bell on all of my application materials, to be offered the position for 30-50% below what I indicated I would accept. HR has strung me along for months only to be dropped. I’ve been brought in to interviews simply so the company can say they’ve done their due diligence and then hire the temporary employee who was already doing the job.

If I am expected to give 250% in an interview and lay myself bare, do I not deserve the same kind of honesty in return? After all, the company is selling itself as much as I’m selling myself. Disclosure is a two-way street. Do these companies not know about websites like Glassdoor in which current and former employees write very detailed descriptions of their work experiences? Do they not realize that job seekers network with each other and share their experiences? I’ve turned down dozens of interviews based on the poor ratings some companies have earned on these sites and based on stories I’ve heard at networking events.

So I am sorry, career consultant, but I respectfully disagree with your advice. I think every job seeker should walk into every interview as prepared, confident and positive as possible. He or she should walk out the door feeling every bit as good about themselves, even if they realize during the interview that perhaps the role or company is not a good fit. Every interview is a valuable experience on some level.

And while there are people who take positions as stepping-stones, I am not one of them. What your article fails to recognize are the many job seekers who want to find the fit and company with whom they can build a lasting career. We are the H that HR seems to overlook in a day and age where you’re only seen as the keywords your software uses to define our life experience. MY advice is to walk into that interview like you own the place, and like they’d be fools not to recognize your potential. Show them what a valuable human resource you are, so that maybe they’ll realize you’re worth keeping for the long haul.

No comments:

Post a Comment