Search This Blog

Sunday, November 3, 2013

I Just Want World Peace, and a Cheeseburger

A few days ago, I posted an article on Facebook about the new obsession women have with attaining the right "thigh gap." The article was the response from a woman who is a size 12 and considered a plus-size model. Basically, it is this very beautiful woman taking a moment to politely tell the world to kiss her healthy ass, and I took a moment on social media to applaud her.

I also made a nodding reference to my servitude in the Texas pageant world, brief as it was, and  recounted a story in which the pageant organizers behind the scenes had already discounted a contestant - before any competition began - because she was considered too fat at a size 6. A dear friend of mine who was a pageant competitor asked me to write a blog about those days, as she is another tremendously beautiful young woman who sadly is considered "plus-size" because she has curves. This is for her and the countless other women who spend their days chasing a beauty ideal into which they have had zero input.

Difficult as this is to believe, I was a makeshift pageant consultant. It happened by virtue of proximity - the guy I was living with in Houston at the time had spent years in the system. For one year, our apartment was pageant preparation central as we tried to help a young woman realize her dreams. During that year, I learned about pageant politics, pageant rules, and that spray glue that keeps a swimsuit from riding up. This was about the time that the Miss Texas and Miss America system was working overtime to change the public's perception of the pageant world. These are scholarship competitions, and not beauty pageants. These young women must be well-rounded, have a topical platform and be a role model to other young women across the nation.

Oh, and they still need to look hot while wearing a two-piece bathing suit and high heels. It's a measure of physical fitness, which is part of being well-rounded. It is in no way sexist, misogynistic or ridiculous (after all, just go to any beach any day and see all of the women who regularly wear Jimmy Choos while walking across the sand).

What I really learned was this:

SIZE MATTERS
Marilyn Monroe would not be able to win a scholarship pageant. At a size 12, she is 8-10 sizes too large to even be taken seriously, in spite of the fact that 40 years after her death men and women still idolize her beauty. Simply put, she would be laughed at and considered fat by pageant standards, just as the girl in my story was not even given a fair chance to compete because she was a size 6.

By comparison, the young woman my partner and I were helping was a size 2 normally, but would go on her pageant diet of salads and laxatives for two weeks prior to competing to get down to a fighting size 0. If you ever want to know why these poor women crack on stage and give stupid interview answers, it's because they are malnourished. The just say world peace because it's quick, it's easy to remember, and it gets them that much closer to the end of the pageant and the beginning of a cheeseburger.

COLOR MATTERS AS WELL
At least it did in Miss Texas. At the time our young woman was competing, Miss Texas had crowned only ONE non-white winner since its inception in 1936. She was possibly the whitest Latina the state could find. The young woman we were helping was a Korean adoptee. She simply didn't stand a chance.

Texas has since crowned African-American winners, but I can't help but feel like it's way too little, way too late. People have stopped watching Miss America, to the point where the organizers tried to turn it into a reality television event to get viewers back online. Diversity hardly counts when it feels like a ploy to regain ratings.

IT'S A BEAUTY PAGEANT
How many times have you watched these pageants and thought, wow, it's so great that these well-rounded young women are advancing the cause of important issues and using their scholarship winnings to better themselves and their communities. Please, there are websites that actually track the pageant while it's happening and rank the contestants based on their hotness factor. Is parading these women around in swimsuits and high heels the only way we can demonstrate that they represent good health, particularly when you can snap most of their bony asses in half with a stiff breeze? Be honest, and let's all admit, we objectify the contestants from the second they do the opening procession.

IT WILL LEAVE YOU NEAR BANKRUPTCY
And let's talk about the scholarship funds. Yes, it's possible to win a good amount of money if you go far in the system. The flip side is that you spend probably 3-4 times that amount to get to the winner's circle. The wardrobe costs a fortune, and you can't compete with the same wardrobe twice. And it's not just what you see on stage, because a lot of the competition happens in preliminaries. That means several sets of interview suits, swimsuits, evening gowns, day suits and ensembles, meet & greet ensembles - even an arrival ensemble, all of which have to be carefully planned and coordinated to present an overall package. We're not taking dresses from JC Penney here. We are talking some very expensive bling, including couture like Chanel, St. John, Badgley Mischka. Even if you break into the Top 10, you have little hope of even breaking even on the amount of time and money you need to invest to get there.

THE WINNER IS CHOSEN LONG BEFORE THE COMPETITION BEGINS
All of the crazy, unhealthy dieting, the personal time sacrifices, the ridiculous amounts of money, and the young woman we were helping never had a real chance of winning. In addition to not being white, every year, we'd all hear the same story. The Miss Texas organizers had their eye on their winner from the second the previous year's competition ended. It was no secret that the organizers knew who they wanted, and that young woman was groomed to within an inch of her life to win. She was given the right regional competition to win, and she was helped every step of the way.

The final straw for my pageant days was when I was asked by my partner to judge a regional pageant that had both a Teen and a Miss contestant. We all knew going in that the Miss winner had already been selected, and that the pageant was just the formality to get her to the state competition. However, I was excited to judge the Teen competition, blindly not realizing that the set up was in place at this level as well. It was only after the pageant that my partner revealed that my scores really didn't matter, because the Teen competition had been stacked to favor the girl they wanted to win. Afterwards, I was floating around the theater feeling extremely used and angry, and I was approached by more than one teen and her mother who were just as hurt and angry as I was. It was then that I realized how staged it all must have looked from their perspective, and I never felt so stupid and ashamed of myself in all my life.

WOMEN ARE DOING THIS TO OTHER WOMEN
It would be easy to blame this all on a sexist male culture, and men are not off the hook here. These pageants are living proof of sexism at its finest. The shocker for me was how many of the Texas regional competitions were organized and run by women, including the state competition for Miss Texas itself, many of them former contestants. It's a bit difficult to completely blame men for this objectification when women are putting their own out on stage to be objectified.

And I have to take one for the gay team here as well, because there are a lot of gay men in the pageant systems. What kind of friends are we being to women if we play a part in this game? And how can we get angry at criticisms of our culture being too obsessed with looks when we openly support a system that perpetuates a beauty idea most women cannot achieve?

I am sorry to say that I contributed to a system that in spite of the shiny scholarship name and ambitions still exists primarily to uphold the unrealistic standards that send women into eating disorders, depression and worse. I highly doubt that I will ever see a "plus-size" pageant winner or one whose thigh gap is deemed unacceptable. There will never be a component of the Miss America competition in which the contestants work to complete a project or innovate a process improvement, develop a scientific theorem or present a business plan - the things we see amazing women do every day. She won't be asked for her opinion on how to best solve healthcare reform or save Social Security. She won't be a size 12 marathon winner or triathlete who has proven her physical and mental accomplishments.

She will never be the kind of role model I want for my daughter.

She'll be at most a size 2, in a two-piece bathing suit and four-inch heels, wishing for world peace and dying for a cheeseburger.


No comments:

Post a Comment