Documentaries are a genre of film I rabidly enjoy and greatly
appreciate. They bring to light some fascinating stories and shed some light in
the dark corners that need our attention. Some uplift, others enrage, and the
best of the breed inspire. Every now and then, some even gain the kind of
momentum that sparks a national dialogue. Amid seas of facts, interviews,
historical footage and hypotheses, these cinematic gems all have one underlying
characteristic: a point of view. Rare indeed is the documentary that is
entirely objective, mostly because I don’t believe any art form can be entirely
objective. Just as we cannot walk through the forest without our presence
changing the environment, an artist cannot create without injecting a small
piece of him or herself into the finished product.
At the request of a friend, I watched a compelling
documentary titled Blackfish. For those not familiar with this film, it tracks the
story of an orca named Tilikum, who was involved in the deaths of three humans
during captivity. Tilikum was a “show whale” at a not-to-be-named marine
zoological institution. Much like the filmmakers who created Blackfish,
I walked in to the viewing with a pretty strong point of view. I have long
railed against keeping these magnificent creatures in captivity for the purpose
of entertainment. Rest assured that watching Blackfish only deepened
my stance against the practice.
I don’t think I can sell the man versus nature story any
better than Blackfish sells it. There is not much I can add to something
that seems so obvious, which is that you cannot oppress that kind of
free-spirited intelligence without paying a price. In this case, the price was
three lives and three sets of families and friends whose worlds are irrevocably
altered. When I try to imagine their pain, I can only think what my reaction
was while watching the film: Is loss of life ever more tragic than when that
loss could have been prevented?
That is where the film left me, pondering how we as the
self-proclaimed dominant species truly don’t get the value of the world we
think we rule. How can we vault ourselves to the top of the food chain – that
we created, let’s not forget – and be so oblivious to how the world actually
works? Worse, how can we acknowledge the beauty and majesty of nature and then
shove it in a glass tank to make it jump through hoops while we drink tankards
of soda and eat trans fats?
One of the major marine zoological institutions issued a
statement after the release of the film claiming that the documentary was
misleading and inaccurate, and too one-sided. Representatives for the
institution were quick to point out all of the good that zoological
institutions do, such as rehabilitating injured wildlife and donating to
conservation and educational programs. Those are true, and that’s why these
institutions have public relations teams to promote the good work they do.
Orcas don’t have publicists, which is why films like Blackfish
need to be made. No, the film didn’t present the other side of the story,
because the film wasn’t titled “Look at All the Good Stuff SeaWorld (my bad) Does.” The film was named after
the animals whose plight is central to the point, which is that you don’t fuck
with Mother Nature. She is a cold and heartless bitch defending her planet, and
she has millions of years of tenure over our species. She’s brilliantly adept
at reminding us that she can knock us off the top in a New York minute. Whether
it’s a captive animal mourning its freedom or a typhoon that wipes out
thousands of lives in a swift and furious stroke, Nature has the upper hand no
matter how evolved we think we are.
It is heartbreaking to think that we exercise our evolved
status to turn intelligent creatures into circus performers, and then stare in
horror when the intelligent creature has the nerve to say, “Sorry, but I’m
better than this, and you should be, too.” It is sad that we put ourselves in a
lofty position of world dominance and remain the only species on the planet that
kills for any reason other than survival.
Our quest to control our surroundings and demonstrate our
superiority frequently leaves us looking like fools. We live in the paths of
volcanoes and typhoons, and then call it a natural disaster when typhoons and
volcanoes do what they are supposed to do – and worse, what we know they are going to do. We are horrified when a killer whale kills a foreign
predator that steps into a cage the foreign predator put it in, yet we applaud
when Joe Six-pack blows away an intruder who sets food on his property.
I have a simple rule that has become sort of a joke with my
friends and family. I don’t swim in the ocean, because there are things in the
ocean that want to eat me. Sharks and I have a clear understanding – I stay out
of their house, and they stay out of mine. If I go snorkeling and Bruce comes
and bites my dumb ass, I can’t get mad at Bruce. After all, it’s not like he
broke into my house – I broke into his.
I’m not saying that I never go where the wild things are. I
do. I just try to leave the wild things where I found them, which is where they
should be. If places like SeaWorld want
to get mad about filmmakers not promoting their good deeds, then SeaWorld
should focus on its good deeds. They can create zoological institutions that
allow people a glimpse into the wild without turning the wild into eight shows
a week with intermission and refreshments. Rehabilitate and rescue marine life,
but do so with the goal of putting that life back where it belongs. It’s a
decision that can save the whale and the person trying to make it jump for
applause.
No comments:
Post a Comment